correct me if i am wrong, but is auto scramble even turned on?

// If set, it will scramble after a team wins X full rounds in a row
gs_winstreak "0"

// If set, it will scramble every X full rounds
gs_scramblerounds "0"

// **************************
// *
// Auto-balance settings *
// *
// **************************

// Max time the teams are allowed to be unbalanced before a balanced is forced on low-priority living players.
// 0 = disabled
gs_ab_max_unbalancetime "60"

Changed to: gs_ab_max_unbalancetime "45"

// Time, in seconds after an imbalance is detected in which an imbalance is flagged, and possible swapping can occur
gs_ab_actiondelay "10"

Changed to: gs_ab_actiondelay "6"

// If teams become imbalanced by this many players, auto-force a balance
gs_ab_forcetrigger "4"

Changed to: gs_ab_forcetrigger "3"

// If less than this amount of time (in seconds) is left in a round, stop auto-balancing.
// "0" will disable this function
gs_ab_timelimit "30"

Changed to: gs_ab_timelimit "45"

// Time in seconds to protect a client from autobalance if they have recently captured a point, defended/touched intelligence, or destroyed a sentry.
// 0 = disabled
gs_teamwork_protect "0"

Changed to: gs_teamwork_protect "15"

// Enables/disables the automatic scrambling.
gs_autoscramble "1"

// Auto-scramble only after a full round has completed.
gs_as_fullroundonly "0"

// If a teams wins with a frag ratio greater than or equal to this setting, trigger a scramble
// 0 = disables this check
gs_as_hfragratio "2.0"

// Starts a scramble vote instead of scrambling at the end of a round
gs_as_vote "0"

// If a team wins in less time, in seconds, than this, and has a frag ratio greater than specified: perform an auto scramble.
// 0 = disables this check
gs_as_wintimelimit "120.0"

// Lower kill ratio for teams that win in less than the wintime_limit.
gs_as_wintimeratio "1.5"

// If the average score difference for all players on each team is greater than this, then trigger a scramble.
// 0 = disables this check
gs_as_playerscore_avgdiff "10.0"

// If a team has this many more dominations than the other team, then trigger a scramble.
// 0 = disables this check
gs_as_domination_diff "5"

// If enabled, trigger a scramble if a team never captures the point in koth mode
gs_as_koth_pointcheck "0"

// If enabled, lock teams when a scramble is about to happen until it happens. This will block clients from changing to spectator
gs_as_lockteamsbefore "1"

// If enabled, lock teams the entire next round after a scramble. This will block clients from changing teams
gs_as_lockteamsafter "0"

// **************************
// *
// global scramble settings *
// *
// **************************

// Minimum people connected before scrambles are possible
gs_as_minplayers "10"

Changed to: "8"

I did do a couple of screenshots actually, but I didn't have the scores up I'll remember next time.

We've finally fixed the HLstatsX API plugin, scrambles should start making more sense again now.