Hey, first post here, so i'll introduce myself. Im an avid 6v6 comp player and a regularly (at least half an hour a day i'd say) on the bball servers. So anyway,
I had a couple of questions to ask regarding the rules on the server:
1) Is shotgun on demo a legal tactic? I hear this being a source of constant whine, however I do tend to think that its actually a perfectly valid tactic and was simply invented by players who aren't particularly good at demo to give them a edge. If someone asks politely then I tend to make sure I don't; however if it goes something along the lines of "ZOMG!!!11!!! DON'T USE SHOTGUN ON DEMO YOU N00B!!" followed by a great number of insults towards ones mother then I tend to just ignore them and continue anyway.
We normally have a plugin blocking the shotgun and disable stikie dmg on enemy's. Last nights TF2 update broke this. We're working on a fix.
2) It is often a great gripe of most players than one player must sit on spec until there is equal times. While I do feel this is perfectly legitimate etiquette for the most part (for example, 2v1), there is of course situations where it doesn't make sense (for example, 3v2 where the 2 players are winning) and yet people will whine anyway.
I'm afraid we can't do much about random whining people. If it gets out of controle you could request an admin on IRC to check the player out.
3) Also, regarding the new weapons released yesterday, would like to know the official stance on this but i'll give my 2 cents after spending 45mins playing with them on the server.
Direct Hit: Perfectly valid, the increased skill to hit a player seems to balance perfectly with the drawbacks so it seems to make sense to keep it.
Equalizer: Brings a fun and interesting new element to the game, I'd personally say keep it.
Charge and Targe & Eyelander: These seem to just cause an annoyance and disrupt gameplay and there is absolutely no way to achieve the objectives of the game with them, I suggest maybe implementing a plugin that removes them from the player when they spawn, similar to the FaN plugin on many TF2DM servers.
We'll look into this. Thanks for the feedback/suggestions.
Also, I would love to see this feature. As the word of a clearly biased player is usually going to be taken with a grain of salt, is there any way we could have a plugin that allows specific rules to be printed in chat by typing something? For example typing: "!shotgunrule" would cause console to print "[SpA Rules] The shotgun is allowed to be used on demomen and soldiers alike."
This shouldn't be nessesary once the plugins are fixed.
Cheers,
Adam
Cheers