They only thing brilliant was the soundtrack. It was Oblivion with guns, and with that I surely want to include the empty dialogues.
Yes, it was Oblivion with guns - and the Fallout universe. That's exactly the reason why I didn't like... OBLIVION. Oblivion had the right gameplay mechanics but the world it was set in was so utterly boring and unoriginal that I couldn't stand it. Innovation in games doesn't necessarily mean reinventing the wheel over and over again especially since this usually results in weird unplayable gimmick titles (see Fret Nice for a recent example of this). Falout 3 combined the Oblivion 3 gameplay mechanics with the Fallout world, both existing separately in the past, to create something new and fresh. Innovation, however, does never mean treading in place like Blizzard is right now, taking existing ideas and mechanics and combining them into... uhm... the same existing ideas and mechanics. ;-)
It's a multiplayer focused RTS. It has nothing to do with artform.
Every game has something to do with that - even the graphics design is done by artists. I have a hard time distinguishing screenshots of SC1 and SC2, they're so similar. And don't give me the "oh, but it's the same universe, you see" kind of response.
There are DOZENS of multiplayer games, no matter the genre, that innovate on the gameplay each year - it's not that difficult to do and it should be even simpler for a company like Blizzard who have dozens of millions of Dollars at their disposal. The more games Blizzard releases, the less original it is becoming... What has become of the company that was once releasing flawed but brilliant classics like Lost Vikings? They have been cutting off coupons of their established franchises for like a decade now, axing projects that might have had even a spark of originality to them like
Warcraft Adventures: Lord of the Clans or
StarCraft: Ghost. It's pitiful that a company that can slap a *Craft sticker to any turd (not saying that they released a turd yet) which would still sell millions is afraid to risk even a single Dollar.
I once loved Blizzard for the hundreds of hours I spent playing their games, especially Diablo 1, but now I grew to literally HATE them since they represent everything that's wrong with the video game industry - they have become the Michael Bay or Roland Emmerich of video games.