from the perspective of a mason->member i like the update.
apart from losing freeze, nothing really changed for me, and i think the whole athmosphere will become way more friendly and creative, because everyone can from now on just build for the sake of building. no more tons of people asking for review, no more dependency on special person`s points of view (at least this is kind of art, and thats alsways a subjective thing), i am eager to see the development on the server, because that is why i originally joined: just build something. i then heard of promotions, tried to be promoted and then, when it happened i first didnt know what to do with new abilities
so i guess the new way also ensures that new players kind of get new tools when they are ready to use them (cut 50 trees with a handsaw to understand how its done before you get the chainsaw for example)
the balancing of abilities is ok i think, but i dont think members need the patrol, it`s enough to be able to kick as a self-defence, without freeze a patrol doesnt make sense. as mason i often patrolled when i didnt want to build, before i saw the use of freeze, i kicked appox. 45 ppl., after realising its power only 16 until now. so my opinion would be "tie" freeze and patrol and leave it to the veterans to clean up
